
Whats
Better? Hardwire or wireless networks?
Deciding to take your network
wireless is a tough call.
Here's a look at some of the pros and cons.
You've determined that the merits of deploying Wi-Fi
across your enterprise outweigh the multitude of
well-publicized issues surrounding Wi-Fi. You've
addressed the standard security concerns. You've
rationalized the alphabet soup of standards. You've
quantified the costs and qualified the benefits.
You've even addressed how you will manage the Wi-Fi
networks once they're deployed.
But have you formulated
a sufficiently compelling case to get approval and
funding? In the face of tough economic conditions,
shrinking IT budgets, and increasing pressures to
do more with less, how will your requests outweigh
the merits of competing internal requests for the
same finite source of funding?
Corporate management tends to be leery of investing
in any emerging technology, especially if you cannot
demonstrate hard benefits and return on investment
and rationalize why it is appropriate to invest
in the current state of that rapidly changing technology.
How will you prepare and present
your case for Wi-Fi investment?
Preparing Your Case for
Management
If your case for Wi-Fi is pragmatic and based on
the reality of available technologies and near-term
anticipated benefits, you will miss an opportunity
to address what is on the minds of those who control
your company's purse strings - namely, what will
happen a year from now when more cellular data and
Wi-Fi alternatives have arrived on the scene. In
order to fully prepare your case and address a longer-term
strategy for Wi-Fi, you will be well advised to
address future wireless data scenarios and lay out
how you see these future scenarios potentially converging
with your near-term Wi-Fi scenario.
In doing so, you will need to address the issues
that management really wants to know about:
Why should I make this particular investment? How
will it impact the business? Will it fundamentally
transform how we do business?
Why should the company
fund your request for Wi-Fi versus investing in
new product development, hiring more sales reps,
upgrading or implementing a new business system,
or making any other investment requested by other
business units?
How will this investment
make the company more competitive? How specifically
will it increase revenues, decrease costs, and/or
increase productivity?
Will the requested
investment generate an ROI, and if so, when?
If the ROI is more
than 12 months out, why are you even considering it?
How will you measure
and prove the ROI?
Should they expect
to see you back again in 12-18 months from now when
cellular data or other Wi-Fi advancements and alternatives
have arrived on the scene?
If so, what happens
to this investment and how much additional funding
will you be likely to request then?
Can these costs be
charged back to the respective departments on a per-user
basis, and if so, what additional effort is needed
to make this happen?
Have the business
units agreed to take on this additional cost?
Your goal should
be to make your request better prepared, more complete,
and more compelling than other investment cases being
presented by other parts of the business.
Where to Begin
To begin preparing your case
for Wi-Fi, address and rationalize your responses
to the following areas of assessment.
1. Wi-Fi Versus Wired
LAN
If a wired LAN does not already exist where you would
like to deploy Wi-Fi, you can get a general sense
of the cost benefits resulting from Wi-Fi deployment
by using the rule of thumb that approximately 10 computing
devices can be supported on a Wi-Fi access point versus
just one device on a hardwired connection. If you
assume that the approximate cost to install each cable
drop is $300 per hardwired connection, you would incur
a cost of $3,000 to hardwire 10 devices, as opposed
to a cost of $300 to hardwire a single access point
that supports 10 devices. Assuming an additional cost
of approximately $1,500 for the access point including
installation, this equates to a total cost of roughly
$1,800 or an approximate cost savings of $1,200 per
every 10 devices on the network. (Note: this is subject
to how many devices a single access point can effectively
support, including factors such as the density of
devices within the area covered by a single access
point, whether access points are deployed to provide
overlapping coverage, and the like.)
In assessing the desire for Wi-Fi versus wired LAN,
justify whether deployment of Wi-Fi will significantly
reduce the need for additional hardwired cable runs,
therefore presenting a cost benefit when compared
to traditional wired deployment. If you are in a scenario
where a wired LAN does not already exist, consider
providing wired connectivity to servers and other
compute-intensive workstations and computing devices,
while using Wi-Fi to support "standard"
desktop use. If you are in a scenario where a wired
LAN already exists, look to provide Wi-Fi in areas
where ad hoc teams form and have a need to collaborate
such as in conference rooms, break rooms, cafeterias,
and "war rooms" (temporary team environments
created to foster close collaboration on time-sensitive
projects).
2. User Adoption
Is Wi-Fi something that will be easy to use, convenient,
and desirable for your end users? If the answer lies
somewhere between "not sure" and "no",
it is unlikely that the introduction of Wi-Fi will
get a much-anticipated welcome, much less continued
use going forward. If there is pent-up demand, however,
the chances of wide user adoption is much greater.
In assessing the demand for Wi-Fi from the user community
and subsequently the likelihood of rousing user adoption,
identify the various user groups, justify how they
will benefit from Wi-Fi, determine whether they have
business-critical or revenue-generating functions
that will be better supported by Wi-Fi, and understand
if these various groups of users are generally accepting
of new technologies and changes to the workplace.
If you can build consensus and anticipation for Wi-Fi
among the user community, your chances of a successful
adoption will be increased.
3. Convergence of Wi-Fi
and Cellular Data
Assuming you have a need for real-time wireless connectivity,
what are the environments in which your various user
groups need connectivity? If wireless connectivity
is predominantly needed within the "four walls"
of your business, Wi-Fi is the leading consideration.
However, if wireless connectivity is predominantly
needed beyond the walls of your business (i.e., for
field service personnel), then cellular data services
such as GPRS or 1xRTT data services provided by mobile
operators should be your leading consideration. Should
you have user groups with a need for both forms of
wireless connectivity (i.e., Wi-Fi and cellular data),
you will then need to rationalize a wireless strategy
that is broader than Wi-Fi alone.
In assessing
the need for Wi-Fi versus cellular data services,
determine when you are better served by investing
in the initial capital expense and ongoing operational
expense associated with Wi-Fi versus the recurring
monthly fees incurred from the use of cellular data
services.
4. Convergence of Wi-Fi
and Cellular Voice
Will the investment in a Voice over Wi-Fi (VoWLAN)
capability drive down the usage and cost of cellular
voice plans and/or will it provide additional capabilities
that will have a quantifiable benefit within your
business? If you have a relatively large employee
population that generates and receives a significant
percentage of their cellular calls within the "four
walls" of your business, VoWLAN should be a consideration.
This should be an even stronger consideration if you
have either an existing VoIP deployment or VoIP-enabled
PBXs.
In assessing the viability of VoWLAN within your business,
first identify what percentage of cellular voice activity
occurs within the walls of your business and then
assess the cost of implementing and operating a Wi-Fi
network that is capable of supporting a VoWLAN capability.
You can then assess the feasibility of this investment
versus "business as usual" with your existing
cellular service. In making this assessment, it is
important to note that VoWLAN will require a Wi-Fi
infrastructure that supports fast authentication in
order to support seamless roaming both between Wi-Fi
access points and in the handoff between cellular
and Wi-Fi networks. A VoWLAN standard, however, is
not expected until later this year.
5. Alphabet Soup
It is essential to know the meanings of current Wi-Fi
standards such as 802.11b, 802.11g, 802.11a, 802.11i,
and the like in terms of their present and future
roles within your business. It is also advisable that
you have an awareness of future standards that have
yet to be ratified and brought to market, such as
802.11e for quality of service (QoS) and the yet-to-be-designated
standard for VoWLAN.
In assessing the alphabet soup of Wi-Fi standards,
if you don't already have access to the necessary
experts, you must be prepared to seek expert assistance
to help you wade through the various competing standards
and technologies and rationalize that which is best
suited to your requirements.
6. Technology Approach
There are two prevailing considerations for technology
selection. The first is whether you plan for a heterogeneous
or homogeneous environment of vendor technologies.
The second is whether you plan for enterprise-grade
or lesser-grade technology.
Identify whether
you will be opting for technology that is standards-based,
thereby allowing you to "mix and match"
technologies that are based on the same standards
(heterogeneous approach) or if you will be relying
on a single vendor's technology in order to take advantage
of their advanced proprietary capabilities (homogeneous
approach). Will you rely on full-featured enterprise
technology that comes with all the bells and whistles
that make it practical to centrally monitor and manage
this equipment? Or, will you rely on fewer-featured
technology that may potentially make deployment or
management more difficult?
7. Security
Security continues to be the black cloud hanging over
Wi-Fi. How will you convince management that, in addition
to the creation and enforcement of underlying policies,
you have addressed all aspects of security, including
those associated with the technology, the physical
security of the premises and equipment, and the tools
and methods to ensure the continued security of the
Wi-Fi deployments in addition to the creation and
enforcement of underlying policies?
Establish guidelines
for what you believe to be a reasonable level of security
for your instance, how you will achieve that level
of security, and the benefits and risks of the approach
you are taking. In short, you must be able to dissuade
concerns of undue risk to the business while demonstrating
the merit of your proposal to address the holistic
requirements around security, both in the initial
Wi-Fi deployments and as an ongoing process. Within
this assessment you must also be prepared to identify
if/how you will monitor for unauthorized Wi-Fi technology
(i.e., rogue access points).
8. Bluetooth
What relevance does Bluetooth have when considering
the deployment of Wi-Fi? Bluetooth is a personal area
network (versus a local area network) that has been
largely used to date as a point-to-point interconnect
method between Bluetooth-enabled devices such as cellular
handsets, PDAs, and printers. You need to be able
to sufficiently differentiate it from Wi-Fi.
9. WiMAX
What relevance does WiMAX (802.16) have when considering
the deployment of Wi-Fi? Recognizing that WiMAX will
be a backhaul solution or a so-called "last mile"
technology for the foreseeable future, it will complement
rather than compete with Wi-Fi.
10. Centralized Management
How do you manage your WAN and LAN environments today?
Do you have centralized or distributed management?
Identify how you will monitor and manage your Wi-Fi
infrastructure, including what additional investments
are required in tools and training or third-party
services and if/how you can leverage your existing
network support capabilities. Due to the need to have
tighter control of your Wi-Fi deployments, it will
be advisable to have a centralized Wi-Fi management
capability.
11. Total Cost of Ownership
Do you have a grasp on what the total cost of ownership
(TCO) is for a single Wi-Fi deployment? A national
Wi-Fi rollout? A global rollout? Address all aspects
of TCO, including the costs required to establish
policies and procedures, a baseline architecture,
technical standards, site surveys, purchasing, integration
and configuration, shipping and logistics, installation,
validation, site-specific installation documentation,
operations procedures, site monitoring and management,
support, and project management.
12. Change Management
Have you considered or perhaps already developed those
policies that will be required to determine which
users across your business will be allowed to use
Wi-Fi? What are the minimum standards for hardware,
OS, and the Wi-Fi client card? If upgrades are required,
how will this be achieved and at whose expense? How
will users be trained? Identify how the Wi-Fi user
community will be properly equipped, prepared, and
engaged in using the new Wi-Fi capabilities.
13. Basis for Your
Business Case
Are you basing your business case for Wi-Fi on increasing
revenue, decreasing cost, or increasing productivity?
Be sure to clearly identify the basis for the investment.
If you are building a business case for Wi-Fi within
an office environment where the benefits are based
on soft productivity increases that may not be sufficiently
compelling in their own right, consider associating
Wi-Fi with facilities improvement, where Wi-Fi is
proposed as a means to improve the work environment.
Peace, Love, and Wi-Fi
While few will question the merits of Wi-Fi, those
who authorize the funding for it will certainly feel
compelled to question the ROI aspects of your business
case, especially if there is any hint of soft benefits
included in the justification. Your course of action
will be to first recognize that you are in fact competing
for a finite amount of internal funding. Then set
out to make your case for Wi-Fi more compelling than
requests to upgrade desktops, introduce a new operating
system, or roll in a new copy machine that will alert
the service organization via your Wi-Fi network when
it is running low on toner. |